Skip to main content

Finally Completing the Puzzle....

I have just been back to the iconic and much-loved Puzzle Hall in Sowerby Bridge for the first time since it re-opened after lockdown. Here's what I found....

The reports had been good. The Puzzle was more like it used to be, the beer was good. Even my brother, who lives in Sowerby Bridge and who can be a glass half-empty man when talking about beer and pubs, was positively effusive. The only thing to do was to go check it out for myself, although previous attempts to get there over the past month or two had come to naught.

So finally, on a damp December Saturday evening, the opportunity arose. I was with my other brother and we walked down from the parents' house high above Sowerby Bridge in the suburbs near the park, reacquainting ourselves with half-forgotten streets and cut-throughs from our childhood intermingled with the buildings and dead ends that had arrived over the intervening decades. The ghosts of our childhood flickered here and there. Dams had been filled in and built on, the old mills that hadn't burnt to the ground now home to apartments. Here and there an unexpected survivor clung on; an old cobbled path, the still intact sign for a long-closed gents here, a unexpected run of railings there. The lights on the opposite hillsides twinkled like stars in the steady drizzle as we cut through the Lidl car park. The sound of a band practising in the room upstairs could be heard as we passed the Blind Pig, the cashpoint outside a reminder that this was once the Yorkshire Bank where I opened the bank account I still use today. We arrived on Hollins Mill Lane, passing the Hollins Mill pub which was once the Works. A little further on, the illuminated sign for the Puzzle Hall was beckoning us towards the pub. 

I have written about the pub before; in 2017 and again in early 2020 so I am not going to go over old ground. a nutshell, here's the back story. Much-loved, quirky pub renowned well beyond the confines of the Calder Valley in which it sits closes. Community group formed amongst regulars and supporters to buy and restore the pub. After successful crowdfunding campaign, work eventually begins to restore the pub after several years of neglect embellished by the odd act of vandalism. Finally in December 2019 said pub re-opens its doors. Three months later, as the country went into the first lockdown, pub closes its doors again, and they don't open until over a year later, completely missing out those strange months of 2020 when pubs could re-open amidst screens, social distancing, limits on group numbers, etc.

I had called in the Puzzle a few times during the brief period after it had re-opened in December 2019, but whilst the restoration work was impressive, I think it is fair to say it wasn't the finished article. Whilst you couldn't expect it to be like it was in the old days, it was the Puzzle, but it wasn't. It didn't seem to have a particular character at that point. Walking in on Saturday evening, the first impression was that it had. A great line up on the bar, groups of people sat in the room as you enter, with a few more occupying tables in the small room where the bar is housed. The fire was lit, there was a comfortable, welcoming feel to the place.

Impressive line up at The Puzzle Hall

I looked at the beers on cask - Rivington Beach House, Marble Pint, North Riding Citra, Bristol Beer Factory, with beers from Wishbone and Fernandes also featured. A good selection from some first-class breweries. Plenty to go at, but we went for pints of Rivington's 3.8% unfined but not too hazy session pale, Beach House, which features Motueka, Mosaic, and Simcoe hops. It was delicious, easily a 4 on the National Beer Scoring System. My brother, who is not a big drinker, enjoyed it too, as we chatted about this and that. The glasses soon emptied - well mine did - and I headed back to the bar to place an order, returning a few minutes later with pints of Sierra Palm from Bristol Beer Factory. This was a beer I had never come across before, a 4% amber ale. I remarked to my brother that I thought I could taste some Sabro hop in there, realising that when he looked mystified I was going into beer geek mode! It was another pleasant ale, which I reckoned was at least an NBSS 3.5, with the usual solid BBF malt foundations with citrus fruit, herbs, and a hint of coconut coming from the hops. I checked on the brewer's website and my suspicions of Sabro weren't entirely misplaced. The beer's hop bill includes HBC 472, which is a brand new breed derived from...drum roll...Sabro! Also featured is Idaho 7, an always dependable American hop variety. It made for an interesting beer all round.

The Puzzle Hall bar

From the other room the sound of conversation was suddenly drowned out by the sound of a drum kit being struck as a band started their sound check. A reminder that despite its small size the Puzzle hosts regular gigs, with a variety of different musical genres and spoken word on the menu. We ordered another drink, going back to the Rivington as we had both agreed how good it was. It was getting time to leave, though, me with a train to catch back to Brighouse. As we were leaving, a guy who had been popping through from the back from time to time and collecting glasses during the evening appeared again. I thought I recognised him, and he said he thought he recognised me too, and it turns out it was the pub's manager, Will Parry, who had worked for a while at the Buffet Bar in Stalybridge when it was well-established as my go-to spot for an after-work pint. Will has ended up here having worked in several places over the intervening years, and based on this evening, he is doing a great job in making the Puzzle an essential place to visit again. The beer was excellent both in terms of choice and quality, the pub was comfortable and welcoming, and I look forward to visiting again before too much longer.

I had no time to visit anywhere else in Sowerby Bridge this particular evening, but when I got back to Brighouse, I walked down into town and called in at the Market Tavern, which like the Crafty Fox a few minutes' walk away, is always a great place to go for a drink. I tend to call in early evenings these days, which means when you go in at a different time you often bump into people you haven't seen for a while, as was the case on this occasion. I was so busy talking I have forgotten what I had to drink (maybe Abbeydale Moonshine?), but it was certainly up to the usual very high standard. If you have never been in, or haven't been for a while, it is well worth calling for the beer - the normal range featuring 3 blonde ales, a stronger pale, an amber, or bitter in old money, and a dark beer - a warm welcome from the team, and friendly conversation.

Welcoming party at the Market Tavern, Brighouse: mine hosts Snap and Debs 

Meanwhile across at The Crafty Fox, which I didn't have time to visit on this particular occasion, the bar is now attracting attention from further afield as it has just joined the Market Tavern in the 2022 Good Beer Guide. It is first time in, and has already cropped up in conversation with some of the pub ticking fraternity who will no doubt be planning visits over the course of the next few months. The bar serves both cask and keg beers from some excellent brewers. The likes of Abbeydale, Salopian, Wilde Child, and Vocation are regularly available on hand pump, whilst on the keg lines there are often beers from Polly's, Neon Raptor, Magic Rock, and Vocation. The Crafty Fox, which is run by Barry Veasey aka Baz, ably supported by wife Michelle, daughter Georgia, son Luke, and sister Kaye, attracts a wide variety of different customers for the beer, live music on Fridays, and its friendly, family atmosphere. And it has the added bonus of being right next door to Brighouse bus station! Another place that if you have not already visited you should check it out for yourself.

Mr Crafty Fox himself...Baz at work

And finally, back to the Puzzle Hall, it is great to see this pub on the up again. I hope that it continues to do well and attract the same loyal following that both the Market Tavern and Crafty Fox a few miles down the Calder Valley in Brighouse enjoy....

Follow me on twitter: @realalemusic


  1. Glad to see it re-open, great news. Excellent pubs in Sowerby now.

    I popped in Crafty Fox for a quick half on Saturday, very impressed and it was packed too !

    1. Thank you, Martin. Sorry I missed you but glad you liked the Crafty Fox! Look forward to reading your report. Simon is due in town tomorrow so it will be interesting to see what he thinks!

  2. My one and only experience of the Puzzle Hall, was in 1977. I was a post-graduate student at Manchester Polytechnic, but was still living in Salford, at the time.

    I was a keen “beer ticker” back then, and the Puzzle Hall was the nearest Wards’ tied pub to Greater Manchester. I had a beaten-up, old Honda 90 motorbike, back then, so one fine summer’s day, I took it for a spin, over to Sowerby Bridge. I’m not sure which route I would have followed but have vague memories of it taking me through Todmorden.

    I located Puzzle Hall without too much problem, and can remember sitting in a room, facing the bar counter. Despite it being nearly four and a half decades ago, I’m pretty certain I sampled both Wards’ beers (bitter and mild). I don’t think they were dispensed by hand-pull though, and most likely were served through electric pumps, of some description.

    Leaving aside the “exotic” (for the time) beers, the pub appealed to me, in a way that’s hard to describe – it might have been its tucked-away location. I always planned to make a return visit, although of course I never did, so next time I’m in that part of Yorkshire, I will stop by.

    1. Hi, Paul, thanks for sharing your memories of the Puzzle. If you are ever in the area please do give me a shout and I'll try to meet up.

    2. I shall certainly do that, Chris. Glad you enjoyed my recollections of Puzzle Hall, from the mid-70's.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Best Buffet Bar None....

One place I am definitely looking forward to visiting again when they re-open is the Buffet Bar in Stalybridge. And whilst it will be great to pay a visit as soon as it is possible, that first visit back to the famous bar on the Manchester Piccadilly to Huddersfield trans-Pennine route will no doubt stir up in me a huge dose of mixed emotions.... Stalybridge Buffet Bar is one of the few remaining Victorian railway station buffet bars left in the country, and is probably the best-known. I started visiting the bar regularly in 2006, when my job meant I was working about a mile and a half away in Hyde. Back in those days, the bar was owned by John Hesketh, who had spotted the potential of the rambling old Victorian station buffet as a real ale mecca. It had originally opened in 1885, and had meandered on over the years quietly serving customers on the trans-Pennine route, but back then it was not known for its beer. John's idea of a good selection of real ales in an atmospheric bar cr

A Calder Valley Ale Trail - UPDATE August 2020

T he definitive guide to the pubs and bars that line the railways in the towns and villages of the beautiful Calder Valley in West Yorkshire, now with an update in light of the 2020 coronavirus pandemic.... August 9th, 2020. The idea for a guide to the pubs along the railway line along the Calder Valley came about as I got fed up with people going on about the Ale Trail from Huddersfield to Stalybridge. I reckoned that the scenery along the Calder Valley was generally more attractive than its southerly rival, and whilst there were some excellent pubs along that route, there were equally some mighty fine pubs in Calderdale. And there was clearly a demand for such a guide: the number of page views I have had for this blog, which has been updated a few times over the years, is several times higher than my next most popular. I had been thinking for some time though that it needed a fresh look and a re-write; the inserted sentences and deleted entries means that it doesn't quite flow

Shades of Grey at The Red Rooster....

A legendary Calderdale pub re-opened its doors a few weeks ago. As a former regular, like many others I have been to check it out. Here's my thoughts.... Sat on a prominent corner in Brookfoot, near Brighouse, the Red Rooster makes for an imposing sight, especially when approached from the front. Even when closed, which it had been since March 2019, it still retained its air of importance, a silent sentinel to a community it was not able to welcome through its doors.  After several months, rumours began to swirl around the area that the pub had been bought and would re-open. Nothing happened, and then we were into the pandemic, when the Rooster was in the same position as every pub that had closed because of lockdown. And then at the back end of 2020, the rumours started up again, only this time with more substance to them. It seemed a family of builders from nearby Shelf had bought the pub with a view to restoring and re-opening it, and then we were into another lockdown. However,