Skip to main content

Are Spoons in Need of a Stir?

Last week pub group JD Wetherspoon posted their results for the 52 weeks to July 24th. Revenue was up 5.4% to £1,595m, profits before tax were up 12.5% to £66m, and earnings per share were up 18.3% to 43.4p.

Commenting on the results, Tim Martin, the Chairman of J D Wetherspoon plc, said: “I am pleased to report a year of progress for the company, with record sales, profit and earnings per share before exceptional items." So, on the face of it a cause for celebration and applause.

The first Wetherspoons opened in Muswell Hill in London in 1979, and they stayed around London for the first few years before expanding to well over 900 pubs across the country. Many of the original pubs featured the word 'Moon' in their name, such as Wembley's JJ Moon, and to this day, several up and down the country include the word, such as Manchester's Moon Under Water, and the Regal Moon in Rochdale. Incidentally, the 'JD Wetherspoon' brand takes its name from one of Tim Martin's teachers back in New Zealand.

Many Wetherspoons have been opened in spectacular buildings that have been the likes of banks, post offices, and cinemas, often listed buildings, often displaying spectacular conversions or restorations, and often with a name reflecting their illustrious past.  They may be newer buildings, part of new leisure developments, old coaching inns, or it may be an old timbered inn such the beautiful Lattice House in Kings Lynn.

There was a time when the arrival of a Wetherspoons in your area was a cause for celebration, a place offering a choice of beers, wines, spirits, and food, all at lower prices than you would find elsewhere. When the Richard Oastler - named as such following a suggestion from my late friend Colin Challender in recognition of the Victorian factory reformer and steward of nearby Fixby Hall - opened in Brighouse 1999 in a former chapel that had more recently  been occupied by an indoor market, it became the must-go-to destination in the town for many years, and at weekends it was packed. We enjoyed our pints of Hop Back Summer Lightning, a beer, like many on offer, not found in our area.

Wetherspoons adopted many new ideas, took advantage of extended licencing hours, were enthusiastic supporters of the smoking ban, and the cafe culture, all the time continuing to provide a generally cheaper offer for food and drink than virtually anywhere else. They have been a long-time supporter of CAMRA with discount vouchers and other benefits, all of which have been much appreciated.

But, increasingly, the formula is starting to look tired. Spoons have always tended to be light on staff as they are expected to cover serving customers at the bar, serving food, clearing glasses, and cleaning tables, and there has always been a tendency to have less people on than are required at busy times. This means queues, even when much quieter, build up regularly. And then there is the frustrating times when 'Coming Soon' is the most common name on the handpump clips, or when you are waiting behind someone who is ordering food, or a coffee when the person serving departs to sort the hot drinks, with the queues building up. OK, many people put up with it when taking the price into account, but in an age where people expect increasingly better service, it is starting to wear a bit thin.

The fact that service seems to have got worse recently was highlighted by my experiences the other week. We went for breakfast at one of the local Wetherspoons before heading off to football. We waited and waited, clearly they were under-resourced. And when it finally turned up, arriving in twos and threes so by the time I got mine everyone else had finished, it was inedible. Slapped on a plate with brittle toast that had been left under a heating lamp for ages, with a broken yolk and stray beans here, there, and everywhere, it was a forlorn sight. 

We stayed overnight that night in Shrewsbury, and after wandering around town on the Sunday morning, we decided to risk another Spoons breakfast. We went in to the place, a guy was on the bandit, a couple were sat by the window, but there were no staff to be seen. We waited. And we waited, before giving up the ghost and heading off to the next place. Now this was another Wetherspoons, but also a hotel, so we reckoned we'd have a better chance. And we did, pleasant staff took our order, the food arrived quickly and was very nice in terms of both presentation and quality. But why should it have taken us 3 attempts to get a decent breakfast?

Other players have come into the market, with cheap drinks and food on offer in so many places, or offering a fresher offer and environment, be it other pubs and pub chains, or just the local cafe or restaurant. Like many large organisations, Wetherspoons seem to have become set in their ways and less nimble and therefore less able to adapt to changing trends. As an organisation they seem to have got out of touch with their customers - the withdrawal last year of Sunday lunches - always very popular - meant several people I know changing their destination. And if you then get better service elsewhere and a better quality product as well, then you may be persuaded to change your allegiance, particularly if you can afford to do so as well.

So whilst the financials may keep the city and investors happy for the time being, unless Spoons catch up with the market, invest more in staff and resources and stop the apparent slide in quality, I do wonder if it will be the same story in another year's time. Watch this space....


Popular posts from this blog

The Best Buffet Bar None....

One place I am definitely looking forward to visiting again when they re-open is the Buffet Bar in Stalybridge. And whilst it will be great to pay a visit as soon as it is possible, that first visit back to the famous bar on the Manchester Piccadilly to Huddersfield trans-Pennine route will no doubt stir up in me a huge dose of mixed emotions.... Stalybridge Buffet Bar is one of the few remaining Victorian railway station buffet bars left in the country, and is probably the best-known. I started visiting the bar regularly in 2006, when my job meant I was working about a mile and a half away in Hyde. Back in those days, the bar was owned by John Hesketh, who had spotted the potential of the rambling old Victorian station buffet as a real ale mecca. It had originally opened in 1885, and had meandered on over the years quietly serving customers on the trans-Pennine route, but back then it was not known for its beer. John's idea of a good selection of real ales in an atmospheric bar cr

A Calder Valley Ale Trail - UPDATE August 2020

T he definitive guide to the pubs and bars that line the railways in the towns and villages of the beautiful Calder Valley in West Yorkshire, now with an update in light of the 2020 coronavirus pandemic.... August 9th, 2020. The idea for a guide to the pubs along the railway line along the Calder Valley came about as I got fed up with people going on about the Ale Trail from Huddersfield to Stalybridge. I reckoned that the scenery along the Calder Valley was generally more attractive than its southerly rival, and whilst there were some excellent pubs along that route, there were equally some mighty fine pubs in Calderdale. And there was clearly a demand for such a guide: the number of page views I have had for this blog, which has been updated a few times over the years, is several times higher than my next most popular. I had been thinking for some time though that it needed a fresh look and a re-write; the inserted sentences and deleted entries means that it doesn't quite flow

Shades of Grey at The Red Rooster....

A legendary Calderdale pub re-opened its doors a few weeks ago. As a former regular, like many others I have been to check it out. Here's my thoughts.... Sat on a prominent corner in Brookfoot, near Brighouse, the Red Rooster makes for an imposing sight, especially when approached from the front. Even when closed, which it had been since March 2019, it still retained its air of importance, a silent sentinel to a community it was not able to welcome through its doors.  After several months, rumours began to swirl around the area that the pub had been bought and would re-open. Nothing happened, and then we were into the pandemic, when the Rooster was in the same position as every pub that had closed because of lockdown. And then at the back end of 2020, the rumours started up again, only this time with more substance to them. It seemed a family of builders from nearby Shelf had bought the pub with a view to restoring and re-opening it, and then we were into another lockdown. However,