Skip to main content

The Good Book Rules....

It's that time of year again....

Every September, there builds up a great and eager sense of anticipation in some circles as the new Good Beer Guide release date approaches. To many though, this feverish excitement felt by these people completely escapes them as their lives carry on as normal, blissfully unaware that to some the publication of this guide is more eagerly awaited than Christmas, or the birth of a new child, or the release of the new season's football fixtures.

It is a time when hopes can be realised, dreams shattered, or years of hard work called into question. Pages are eagerly-turned, favourites sought out to see that they have made the cut. And likewise they are scoured for those places that are now in, maybe a favourite, maybe one you would vehemently oppose.

For some, whose life's work is to complete every pub in the beer guide, it is the start of a year to plan. More gaps to fill in, more trips across the length and breadth of the country, maybe including a visit to a location only visited a few weeks earlier where there is now a new addition.

And for me, there were a couple of seismic changes to hit my local area. For more years than I can remember, the Three Pigeons in Halifax has been a regular in the Guide. Not in the 2019 edition, a reflection of what has frankly been variable beer quality over the  past year or two. Likewise The Star in Folly Hall, Huddersfield has been a fixture for years, but it just shows that increased pressure from up and coming rivals will eventually win through in areas that seemingly are a closed shop. So, great that in Halifax, the Alexandra and Square Chapel have been recognised, along with this blog's latest poster boys, the Wainhouse Tavern in Pye Nest, also making it into the Guide.

But for those places that didn't make it this time, it doesn't have to be the end of the road. With the right approach, a re-think, a step back to review, and the will to recover from the shock of being dropped, or not quite making the cut, it is often the spur to come back, stronger, fitter, and all the more experienced in a year or two's times.

So, as ever, the release of the new Good Beer Guide is for some a cause for celebration, for others disappointment, and for others a spark for planning new places to visit. But for all of them it is the source of great debate....

New to the Guide: The Wainhouse Tavern, Halifax


  1. Chris thanks for your well thought out and reasoned piece - it is always tricky to select just a few pubs from the many in our Branch. There is a debate to be had about the merits of Town vs Country, old vs new but the quest remains The Good Beer Guide so all have the aim of keeping and selling good quality beer.

    1. Thanks for your comments, Tony, appreciate it is very difficult to achieve a balanced selection in what is an increasingly changing scene, and so that the Good Beer Guide can only reflect the situation at one point in time. In terms of the changes within our area, the Alexandra and Square are well worth their places, whilst in Hebden Bridge, Drink? has been excellent for a long time, but as I say, for the ones that lose out this time, it can be the jolt required to spur them on to come back stronger and fitter!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Best Buffet Bar None....

One place I am definitely looking forward to visiting again when they re-open is the Buffet Bar in Stalybridge. And whilst it will be great to pay a visit as soon as it is possible, that first visit back to the famous bar on the Manchester Piccadilly to Huddersfield trans-Pennine route will no doubt stir up in me a huge dose of mixed emotions.... Stalybridge Buffet Bar is one of the few remaining Victorian railway station buffet bars left in the country, and is probably the best-known. I started visiting the bar regularly in 2006, when my job meant I was working about a mile and a half away in Hyde. Back in those days, the bar was owned by John Hesketh, who had spotted the potential of the rambling old Victorian station buffet as a real ale mecca. It had originally opened in 1885, and had meandered on over the years quietly serving customers on the trans-Pennine route, but back then it was not known for its beer. John's idea of a good selection of real ales in an atmospheric bar cr

A Calder Valley Ale Trail - UPDATE August 2020

T he definitive guide to the pubs and bars that line the railways in the towns and villages of the beautiful Calder Valley in West Yorkshire, now with an update in light of the 2020 coronavirus pandemic.... August 9th, 2020. The idea for a guide to the pubs along the railway line along the Calder Valley came about as I got fed up with people going on about the Ale Trail from Huddersfield to Stalybridge. I reckoned that the scenery along the Calder Valley was generally more attractive than its southerly rival, and whilst there were some excellent pubs along that route, there were equally some mighty fine pubs in Calderdale. And there was clearly a demand for such a guide: the number of page views I have had for this blog, which has been updated a few times over the years, is several times higher than my next most popular. I had been thinking for some time though that it needed a fresh look and a re-write; the inserted sentences and deleted entries means that it doesn't quite flow

Shades of Grey at The Red Rooster....

A legendary Calderdale pub re-opened its doors a few weeks ago. As a former regular, like many others I have been to check it out. Here's my thoughts.... Sat on a prominent corner in Brookfoot, near Brighouse, the Red Rooster makes for an imposing sight, especially when approached from the front. Even when closed, which it had been since March 2019, it still retained its air of importance, a silent sentinel to a community it was not able to welcome through its doors.  After several months, rumours began to swirl around the area that the pub had been bought and would re-open. Nothing happened, and then we were into the pandemic, when the Rooster was in the same position as every pub that had closed because of lockdown. And then at the back end of 2020, the rumours started up again, only this time with more substance to them. It seemed a family of builders from nearby Shelf had bought the pub with a view to restoring and re-opening it, and then we were into another lockdown. However,